The tax estimate looks too high Live
Paycheck withholding isn't subtracted; flagged items and the high end of the range affect still-to-fund
The tax estimate looks too high Live
If MoneySupply’s recommended tax set-aside seems higher than you expect, there are a few common reasons why the estimate might look inflated. Understanding how the calculation works will help you interpret the number correctly.
Paycheck withholding isn’t subtracted
If you have a W-2 job in addition to your business, your employer withholds federal and state taxes from every paycheck. These withholdings count toward your total tax liability for the year.
MoneySupply’s estimate does not account for W-2 withholding. It only looks at your business profit and assumes you need to set aside tax on that profit. Your actual quarterly payment obligation may be lower because of the withholding you’ve already paid through your employer.
What to do
If you have significant W-2 withholding, consider:
- Reducing the amount you fund in the Tax bucket to reflect your true obligation
- Consulting a tax professional to calculate your exact quarterly estimate
- Waiting until customer accounts are available and MoneySupply supports inputting W-2 withholding
TODO(Jason): Clarify whether MoneySupply will add a feature to input W-2 withholding and adjust the estimate accordingly.
The effective rate is conservative
MoneySupply uses a default effective tax rate that errs on the high side to help you avoid underpayment penalties. This rate includes:
- Federal income tax (based on a typical bracket)
- Self-employment tax (approximately 15.3% on net profit)
- State income tax (assuming California rates)
If your actual tax situation results in a lower rate (e.g., you have deductions or credits not reflected in MoneySupply), the estimate will look too high.
Flagged items increase the estimate
If you’ve flagged certain transactions as “to be reviewed” or haven’t categorized them as deductible, MoneySupply may be calculating profit on a higher income figure than your true taxable profit.
Check that:
- All deductible business expenses are categorized correctly
- Non-business expenses paid from a business account are flagged as non-deductible or moved to Personal
- Reimbursable expenses (paid on behalf of a client) are not counted as income
The high end of the range
MoneySupply sometimes shows a range for the recommended set-aside (e.g., “$5,000 - $6,200”). The “still to fund” amount may be based on the high end of the range to give you a buffer. If you’re comfortable with the lower end, you can fund less.
Today’s estimate assumes a California S-corp
The tax estimate assumes:
- You’re operating as a pass-through entity (sole proprietor, LLC, or S-corp)
- You’re filing as married filing jointly (for the default effective rate)
- You’re subject to California state income tax
If your situation differs (single filer, different state, C-corp), the estimate may not be accurate.
TODO(Jason): Add support for customizing tax settings (state, filing status, entity type) to improve estimate accuracy.
Next steps
Learn about The daily brief didn’t arrive or explore Chat in the app didn’t reach Fin for more troubleshooting tips.