Why is a transaction still in Approvals? Live
Pending items, items before tracking start date, and how keep, change, and undo work
Why is a transaction still in Approvals? Live
If a transaction is lingering in your Approvals inbox longer than you expect, there are a few common reasons why it might not be moving to your main register or being finalized.
Pending transactions
Pending transactions (items that haven’t posted yet at the bank) may appear in Approvals but are not fully actionable until they settle. MoneySupply waits for the transaction to post before finalizing the categorization.
Once the transaction posts, it will either:
- Move out of Approvals automatically (if Fin is confident about the category)
- Remain in Approvals for your explicit keep, change, or undo action
Transactions before your tracking start date
Transactions dated before your tracking start date are stored in MoneySupply but excluded from active processing. They won’t appear in:
- The Approvals inbox
- The Monday uncategorized digest
- Uncategorized transaction counts
This is by design, so older transactions don’t clutter your current work. If you want to categorize a pre-tracking-date transaction, you can manually navigate to it in your full register and assign a category.
Ambiguous transactions
If Fin, your MoneySupply assistant, lacks confidence about a transaction’s category, it may leave it in Approvals longer than usual, waiting for you to provide explicit guidance. This often happens with:
- Merchants Fin hasn’t seen before
- Transactions with vague descriptions (e.g., “PURCHASE AUTH” or “POS DEBIT”)
- Transfers between your own accounts (which may not need a category)
How keep, change, and undo work
When you review an item in Approvals:
- Keep: Accept Fin’s suggested category and finalize the transaction in your register
- Change: Select a different category, then confirm—the transaction is finalized with your chosen category
- Undo: Remove Fin’s suggestion and leave the transaction uncategorized (it returns to the pool and may reappear in Fin’s next auto-categorize run)
If you undo a transaction, it’s not finalized—it remains uncategorized and will likely show up in the Monday digest or future Approvals.
Duplicate transactions
Sometimes a pending transaction posts with a slightly different amount or description, creating what looks like a duplicate. MoneySupply tries to detect and merge duplicates, but if you see two similar transactions in Approvals, check your bank statement to confirm which one is real and undo or delete the duplicate.
TODO(Jason): Clarify whether MoneySupply provides a “mark as duplicate” or “merge transactions” feature.
Next steps
Learn about Why can’t I email this invoice? or explore The tax estimate looks too high for more troubleshooting tips.